as Richard said check your polarity as LED's are polar sensitive, I fitted Have fitted LED interior (LandCruiser) light x2 Globes and they took different type globes, one of them had some sort of self correction built in the other a Festoon type globe did not and only works in direction, turn it about face and it does nothing,
Also another thing to check is that OEM indicators are insulated both neg and pos from bike which is why Richards OEM ones would have worked, but if your new LED ones earth thru the indicator body as mine do and one of your wire were incorrectly connected at the factory so you might be actually be connecting an positive wire to an earth, to check replace your fuse disconnect the all indicators wires and check each one with ignition on and indicators active. I hope this make sense to you