Roadster shocks are definitely an improvement over the original ones on my '09 Standard. Ride is still pretty firm but the big bumps don't kick as much. Haven't tried any others, mainly because for every happy camper there seems to be several not satisfied after having spent big bucks. If I'm going to fork out many $00 I want to be certain there'll not only be an improvement, but a big one.
Just a thought; what setting are yours on? I set my old ones on 3 and it made a significant difference comfort wise.