Sounds like a good trade. As long as your happy with the different riding style... shouldnt be a problem. Remember its what you want Just dont expect to "cruise" with the tiger and I have to believe (i have never rode a tiger) the rocket would be more comfortable over longer trips and such. Good luck!
After a long ride on the Classic with the wife yesterday, I realized that the Tiger, although a great ride I'm sure, would not be the one to go with for the two of us. I would consider it as a cool addition to the stable, however. Thanks for all the responses--glad I finally came to my senses.