I sold my 03 Vmax last year and came to the R3 roadster. The Vmax is a blast to ride, but now that I have logged some miles on my new bike I prefer the rocket. Better range (if you are taking it easy), more comfortable, and I just like the looks of the Rocket better...dual headlight, chrome and black etc. The Vmax's are great/quick bikes, but I will stick with the Triumph!
With that said I havent tried the new Vmax's, but with what sounds like worse range, that is a deal breaker for me even though they look awesome.