Ty,
Have come to appreciate the bag a lot. Quite handy. It does rub a bit on the fender, over the course of a season leaving some scuff marks. A negative, but, suppose any other bag so designed would do the same? Straps down tight and handily/tidy; has been at “very illegal” speeds often enough, had no snake heads left on rear at seasons end, so yes, have challenged the mounting - no issues. Found on amazon, $100 or so, not a big risk to try out.
Lotus,
Yeah, the right pannier departed on a 90mi jaunt to the city. Never felt or heard a thing. Looked and looked along route to no avail. Cost me a few hundred bucks, plus a lockset, and 3 mo’s wait or so? Ship happens.
If i’ve a pillion, the factory panniers are a given, and do like them. If going solo, kind of a coin toss; the bag is handier to carry into a hotel vs two full panniers, so there’s that.