I also have both for my Touring and don't much like either one. I get a lot of buffeting with the standard but prefer it during summer local and short haul riding. For long range, multi state riding in inclement weather I prefer a tall screen.
I must say that your tall screen appears to be a Clearview, to me the best aftermarket screen on the market. It appears to have a recurve and they have a vent option.
I'll be replacing my stock Triumph tall screen with one of them shortly. I had one on my 07 Classic