If you do pull the center bolt and spring out, do not turn the bike over or rock it back and forth until you put the bolt back in. Myself I would not try to force it to the next tooth but its your call. You need to measure the drop of the plunger to see if its gone past 16 mm if so then there is a spacer you add to return the spring tension to original tension. Since yours is a 2013 I suspect the drop has not gone to far. How many miles are on it? I must ask is the rattle on the left of the engine or the right ?(as you sit on it)