Why all the whining ????

Can't Hear It

But, with the Jars, I have to wear earplugs when I ride. It's not that they're too loud, but for some reason the exhaust note really resonates in my Scorpion EXO1000 helmet...
 
The cams and chains make alot of that noise, you don't hear it in push rod motors like harleys but it's very prevelent in big jap bikes too. Overhead cam engines have alot of chain to spin, that's why (along with cost) cheap cars ran timing belts instead. An exotic or muscle car can get away with noises like that but when you drive a sewing machine no one wants to hear chain whine, intake whistle or injector clack. Besides, belts slip and fail, on tight clearance engines where they can't "free wheel" without the valves hitting the pistons .... BOOM! serious engine damage. Chains are noisy but much stronger and more reliable than belts. It's a trade off.
I have a little more whine than I should but it's my waterpump, for whatever reason Triumph looked at it and said it was normal. I don't believe them for a second but I still have another year left on the the warranty and will wait till it either fails or throw a fit just before the warranty expires.
You can isolate the location of the noise with a stethescope or a big screw driver. Hold the grip of the screw driver pressed to your ear and touch the other end to different areas of the engine while its running. You probably already know that trick but someone else might not.
 
Last edited:
The whine is most probably the straight cut gears used to transfer the drive from the crank to the clutch and the balance shaft.

"In short, helical gears operate quieter than straight cut. Straight cut will 'whine' the faster they go but offer both A. More directional application of force allowing for less power loss. and B. Higher acceptable loads until failure. Basically making the transmission stronger and more efficient. However though, like noted before, car manufacturers don't use straight cut due to the imense noise the transmission will produce."
 
Goth is right about spur gears (straight teeth) being noisy compared to helical gears. But Helical gears are much much stronger. The standard is to have a helix angle of not more then 20 degrees to keep thrust axial loads under control. this is not to say you can't have a helix angle higher the 20 degrees its just far and few. The only gear stronger the a helical is the herring bone which is sometimes call a double helical.
If you look at it closely there is a spur gear of the same diametral pitch inside every helical gear its just at a angle.
 
Thanks for all the input I really wasn't too worried, just seems like the nature of the beast. I just thought if there was something I could do to quiet her down while I was doing the timing chain (due to the paint can rattle) I would kill 2 birds with 1 stone.
 
I always thought it was just a Triumph thing. If it ain't noisy, the motor ain't running.

A quote from Watsonian at the fall Launch, "Thats a Rocket I hear, I can tell cause it sounds like a tractor f*ucking a sewing machine!"
That about sums it up.
 
Back
Top