Mine has the same issue...
I purchased a new 2008 several weeks ago. I noticed right away that whenever I filled it up, it took awhile to get back to the full mark and after staying there a few miles it would drop like a stone to between 3/4 and 1/2 full. However, I've learned to ignore it. It shows over 200 miles remaining on the display after it's filled up so I don't worry about it. Also, I've checked the accuracy of the miles remaining when you get low on fuel and mine is fairly accurate. I let it get down to 1 mile to go and had to put in almost 5 gallons.